Would a Muslim really become an infidel if he says that Prophet Muhammad made mistakes before?

No reference to Gibril Fouad Haddad's quote!

Throughout this rebuttal, I am assuming that the quote is Gibril Haddad's, since there is no email reference or anything to verify it! However, the quote could be another sick lie by Jalal Abualrub put on the mouth of Gibril Haddad.

Would a Muslim really become an infidel if he says that Prophet Muhammad made mistakes before?

1- The dajjal's statement and my response to it.
2- The mistakes of Prophet Muhammad.
3- So did Prophet Muhammad make a mistake in interpreting the Noble Quran?
4- Conclusion.

In one of his absurd articles, the desperate salafi dajjal who is way too desperate to prove that I am an infidel, dished out another absurd article by yet another ignorant author of his called "Dr. Gibril Haddad". Let us see how knowledgeable this so-called doctor is.

I am shocked, not that "One brother even declared Mr. Abdallah a kafir (murtad) after reading some of his views on matters related to Islam" but that only one brother did. When someone calls our Prophet, upon him blessings and peace, "mistaken" about the meaning of the Qur'an, or calls Sayyidina `Isa, upon him peace, "the Beast", whoever doubts that such a person is a kafir are themselves kafir. Such can only be the view of an evangelist (which is my hunch concerning this person) or a murtadd of the so-called "qur'an-only" heresy (which is more plausible), and Allah is our refuge from their poison. Some consider him a scholar! A scholar!! Can they have become so impoverished that they search garbage for something to wear? It will not do to say "Of course, none of us are scholars and so we are in no position, or authority, to judge whether someone is a kafir or deviant." We need no further proof when the apostasy is as clear as the sun, since this person has questioned the Messengership of the Prophet, upon him blessings and peace, as the conveyer not only of the Qur'an but its bayan as mentioned in several verses. This person (whoever he is) claims that "Satan... will eventually end up in Heaven." Then let this "Osman Abdullah" pray to Allah subhan wa-ta`ala to resurrect him with Satan.

Gibril Haddad (Source) [This source itself contains no reference!]

First of all, this long gone piece of information that these barking dajjals wouldn't let go of, because it is their only and desperate piece against me, had not only been removed from my site because I changed my previous Quran-only beliefs or inclinations toward that deviant belief, but I also wrote a nice article defending Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, about his statement about sunset and where the sun goes and proved that even scientifically, his statement wasn't "utter nonsense" as I said before.

So not only did I repent from that statement and left my previous deviant beliefs after long and hard research for the Truth, but I also researched further and found out that Prophet Muhammad's statement wasn't at all in any contradiction or hostility with science.

So why wouldn't those desperate salafi liars drop their nonsense about apostatizing me? Perhaps this this their cheap way to justify their utter failures to defend Islam like I do, by looking busy in front of their readers and to undermining my Islamic beliefs.

"And when the Word is fulfilled against them (the unjust), we shall produce from the earth a beast (dabbah) to (face) them: He will speak to them, for that mankind did not believe with assurance in Our Signs. (The Noble Quran, 27:82)"

When evil rules over earth, Allah Almighty will produce a beast to face evil. "dabbah" is not just limited to animals. It also covers humans:

"For the worst of beasts (dawab) in the sight of God are those who reject Him: They will not believe. (The Noble Quran, 8:55)"

I initially claimed that it is possible that the beast in Noble Verse 27:82 is referring to Prophet Isa (Jesus), peace be upon him, since we Muslims believe that he will come back to earth to fight the anti-Christ and his army.

3- Regarding me being "garbage", Muslims being impoverished, and Hell eventually Ending:

As for Hell's Punishment Ending, I first of all never limited the subject to satan only and said that he alone will end up in Heaven. What I said was that there is Islamic evidence that Hell's Punishment will eventually End, and this even includes satan's punishment. But satan wasn't my main point and focus here! Life is finite; the Life-after is infinite. Satan's problem with GOD Almighty is finite, and his defiance to GOD Almighty and strife of spreading mischief among GOD Almighty's creations are also finite. GOD Almighty's Mercy is infinite. With this simple philosophy, I believe that it is quite possible that the punishment of Hell might end at one point. It is also quite possible that timing of the beginning and end of Hell will be as the Universe began and ended (when Judgment Day comes).

Not only that, but there is a Qudsi Hadith (a Saying inspired by the Holy Spirit to Prophet Muhammad) that says:

Narrated Abu Huraira: "Allah's Apostle said, 'When Allah completed the creation, He wrote in His Book which is with Him on His Throne, 'My Mercy overpowers My Anger.' ' (Translation of Sahih Bukhari, Beginning of Creation, Volume 4, Book 54, Number 416)"

So it is quite possible that Allah Almighty's Wrath, Anger and Punishment will end because His Eternal Mercy always overpowers His Angry and Punishing side. That's it.

As to me being garbage and my readers being impoverished, I never claimed to be a scholar nor do I care about such titles that you and the phonies like you are fond on, who deliberately twist words and put them out of context as you did with mine, when in reality you are both arrogant and ignorant in many aspects regarding Islam.

Again, no reference to Gibril Fouad Haddad's quote!

Again, I am assuming that the quote is Gibril Haddad's, since there is no email reference or anything to verify it! However, the quote could be another sick lie by Jalal Abualrub put on the mouth of Gibril Haddad.

Anyway, going back to the Prophet made a mistake issue, let us now look at the bigger picture here. Was Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, really perfect? Did he really not make mistakes before?

"(The Prophet) frowned and turned away, Because there came to him the blind man (interrupting). But what could tell thee but that perchance he might grow (in spiritual understanding)?- Or that he might receive admonition, and the teaching might profit him? As to one who regards Himself as self-sufficient, (The Noble Quran, 80:1-5)"

"O Prophet! Why holdest thou to be forbidden that which God has made lawful to thee? Thou seekest to please thy consorts. But God is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful. (The Noble Quran, 66:1)"

Anyone with the least amount of brain would immediately see that Allah Almighty brought to the Prophet's attention his mistakes and even warned him against them. In fact, ".....thou seekest to please they consorts. But God is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful...." is a powerful statement and warning to the Prophet!

I am not saying that Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, is a sinner here. But to consider him absolutely perfect and never made any mistake and to apostatize anyone who claims that the Prophet wasn't perfect is quite absurd and contradicting to the Noble Quran Itself.

Initially, I thought he did, but after doing more research it turned out that he never did; peace, mercy and blessings be upon him. I personally never take blind faith and lies as Truth. If Prophet Muhammad says that 1+1=3 then I would be the first to refute him! But so far, Islam has truly proven Itself to be a Divine Truth from GOD Almighty, where I am able to live a pure and chaste life by following Allah Almighty's Holy Commands, and His Divine Commands truly stood the grilling of science and the test of time.

I am not a Muslim because my parents are Muslims or because I am following Islam blindly. I have researched Islam thoroughly and saw that the Noble Quran truly proved Itself to be a Miraculous Holy and Divine Book from GOD Almighty. Today, I am a Muslim only because I am 100% convinced that Islam is the Divine Truth that was sent down from none other than GOD Almighty to our Blessed and Beloved Prophet, Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him.. Having this type of faith makes me much stronger and more committed to Islam than the blind followers who are too afraid of everything.

Again and again, the desperate and hateful salafi liar and dajjal, Jalal Abualrub (abul-rub, abu-alrub), had been soundly exposed and refuted by Allah Almighty's Will and Grace on this web site, and his salafi cultists had been exposed to be hateful and liars who are willing to fabricate lies against any non-salafi Muslim to prove that he/she is an infidel. Such sick and demented people must always be fought and exposed!