Answering Christianity Research Center

You should also take a look at this Wikipedia page (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_in_the_Bible).

So do we have to accept the other 6 Hadiths commanding death to the one who does it, or ibn Abbas' opinion that there is no prescribed punishment? The first Hadith also has Abu Huraira in the chain.

Assalamu alaikum.

I was reading Hadiths on bestiality when I noticed something weird:

Translation:  Whoever comes unto an animal, kill him and kill it with him.
Narrator:  Abu Huraira and Ibn Abbas.
Validity and Authentication:  Authentic and undisputed.
Reference:  Sahih Al-Jami'a, page or number: 5938.

Translation:  Whoever comes unto an animal, kill him and kill it with him.
Narrator:  Abdallah Ibn Abbas.
Validity and Authentication:  Authentic and undisputed.
Reference:  Mushkat Al-Masabeeh, page or number: 3509.

Translation:  Whoever goes in unto (has sex with in other words in Arabic) an animal, kill him and kill the animal.
Narrator:   Abdallah Ibn Abbas.
Validity and Authentication:  Chained by Amru bin Abu-Amru.  Both disputed it.  But Yahya bin Ma'een authenticated it.
Reference:   Nile Al-Awtar, page or number 7/288.

Translation:  Whoever you find unto (having sex with) an animal, kill him and kill the animal with him.
Narrator:  Abdallah Ibn Abbas.
Validity and Authentication:  Authentic and undisputed.
Reference:  Sahih Al-Tirmithi, page or number: 1455.

Translation:  Whoever you find unto (having sex with) an animal, kill him and kill the animal with him.
Narrator:  Abdallah Ibn Abbas.
Validity and Authentication:  Authentic and undisputed.
Reference:  Sahih Al-Jami'a, page or number: 6588.

Translation:  Whoever goes in unto (having sex with) an animal, kill him and kill the animal.
Narrator:  Abdallah Ibn Abbas.
Validity and Authentication:  Authentic and undisputed.
Reference:  Sahih Ibn Majaa, page or number: 2094.

Narrator:  Kill the doer and the one who is being done (i.e., two males having sodomy), and who goes in unto an animal.
Narrator:  Abdallah Ibn Abbas.
Validity and Authentication:  Authentic and undisputed.
Reference:  Sahih Al-Targheeb, page or number: 2423.


However, in Sunan Abu Dawood, here is what it said:

Book 38, Number 4449:
Narrated Abdullah ibn Abbas:

The Prophet (peace_be_upon_him) said: If anyone has sexual intercourse with an animal, kill him and kill it along with him. I (Ikrimah) said: I asked him (Ibn Abbas): What offence can be attributed to the animal/ He replied: I think he (the Prophet) disapproved of its flesh being eaten when such a thing had been done to it.

and:

Book 38, Number 4450:
Narrated Abdullah ibn Abbas:

There is no prescribed punishment for one who has sexual intercourse with an animal.

Abu Dawood said that the second narration is more correct.

I don't understand. Can someone explain about multiple authentic Hadiths contradicting an authentic Hadith?

Thanks.

Never mind I will do it myself.

OK everyone. Since I'm sure Sina won't reply to me, can someone be kind enough to send him an email? I will PM him/her and tell him/her what to say.

1.

Not a contradiction at all because the first hadees is not found in any authentic source, (as I searched)

2.

Even this hadees is not found in any authentic source.(as per my search)

I found the answer to no. 1. But i'm not sure for 2. I can't just dismiss a hadith without proving it.

OK, I'm still a bit confused. The Quran says:

And no person can ever die except by Allah's Leave and at an appointed term. And whoever desires a reward in (this) world, We shall give him of it; and whoever desires a reward in the Hereafter, We shall give him thereof. And We shall reward the grateful.
(3:145).

How can you Allah's leave by doing suicide bombing?