Answering Christianity Research Center
MAIN BOARD (You must register to post) => GENERAL TOPICS | BOARD ANNOUNCEMENTS => Topic started by: muslimforever2012 on September 01, 2017, 02:24:29 PM
-
Assalamu alaikum and Eid mubarak everyone.
I know I asked this before, but I just need this last answer. A Christian told me that he knows that marrying children were common but he told me that Muhammad was wrong in marrying Aisha because:
1. Aisha was 6 and she didn't hit puberty and couldn't consent. He told me that she probably didn't even know about marriage.
2. He said Muhammad's example was for all time and in this time child marriage is not appropriate.
I told him about the child marriages in the Bible but he said their example was not for all time.
Sorry if I disturbed anyone.
Thanks.
-
-
Wa-alaikum-salam
Muhammad (SAWS) told Aisha that a girl who is silent must be consulted for marriage, according to several hadith.
In fact, when a girl asked the Prophet about her complaint for forced marriage, he supported her rights.
Regarding Aisha's age, she said that she already reached her puberty, so I think that 6 or 9-year-old in a hadith is an error.
Besides, other Muhammad's wives were much older than Aisha whatsoever.
If he was a pedophile, than he would marry all young girls.
-
This Iraqi guy wrote an interesting and thought provoking article concerning this subject....you should also check the comments....
http://azblogtalk.blogspot.com/?m=1
-
This Iraqi guy wrote an interesting and thought provoking article concerning this subject....you should also check the comments....
http://azblogtalk.blogspot.com/?m=1
I couldn't find the article. Can you please give me the link?
-
The article is infact a rebuttal to the Masked Arab....
http://azblogtalk.blogspot.com/2016/02/why-masked-arab-is-masked-falsehood.html
-
-
-
-
-
-
Hani,
Muslimdude is honest, but you still don't get it.
I know that one authentic hadith where Moses (phub) hit an angel to death, which is considered a blasphemy.
So, does this mean Moses is satanic?
-
Assalamu alaikum.
Thanks everyone for the answers. Can anyone from you please join me in the Faithfreedom forums? I debated with them and I still am but tomorrow I'll be busy for a long time.
-
I would but the issue is I live in UAE where sites such as FaithFreedom are blocked.
-
Assalamu alaikum.
Thanks everyone for the answers. Can anyone from you please join me in the Faithfreedom forums? I debated with them and I still am but tomorrow I'll be busy for a long time.
Wa Alaikum As'salam dear brother,
Just provide links. Do not waste your breath debating these doomed-to-Hell losers. Let the Muslims' articles do the talking. This way, you promote Muslim links.
Take care,
Osama Abdallah
-
Assalamu alaikum.
Thanks everyone for the answers. Can anyone from you please join me in the Faithfreedom forums? I debated with them and I still am but tomorrow I'll be busy for a long time.
Wa Alaikum As'salam dear brother,
Just provide links. Do not waste your breath debating these doomed-to-Hell losers. Let the Muslims' articles do the talking. This way, you promote Muslim links.
Take care,
Osama Abdallah
Thanks, but those people are so fussy they wouldn't read them.. Let me tell you what happened there:
1. I proved that the murder of Asma bint Marwan was false due to Waqidi, but they started making excuses, saying that liars don't always lie etc etc.
2. I disproved the rape theory of Safiyyah using an authentic Hadith, but then they lost their mind and told me that doesn't make sense due to the murder of her father and husband.
3. I proved to them that Muhammad was not the only one who saw angels using a Bukhari Hadith, but one of them said that the companion (Sa'ad ibn Abi Waqas) who narrated the Hadith was a murderer and a liar (astaghfirullah).
4. I showed them that the Hadith of Muhammad kissing Hussein's penis was unreliable, but one of them said that it is only weak and weak doesn't always mean false (lol wat?).
5. They even jumped to the extent of saying that ISIS is the best of Muslims.
Bro Osama I wish you were there so you can see their stupidity. I don't want $50k. I want to see that stupid site being shut down once and for all.
You can use a proxy or a VPN. Search for tutorials on how to get them for free.
I would but the issue is I live in UAE where sites such as FaithFreedom are blocked.
-
Oops sorry mistype:
I would but the issue is I live in UAE where sites such as FaithFreedom are blocked.
Search for free VPNs.
-
Albarra,
Firstly which hadith says that moses killed an angel, next yku sajd there was 1 hadith about it, the age of aisha is so many ahadith where she herself says it, i can bring you more then 10 sahih ahadith whixh are mutawatir, with chains including hisham and excluding hisham, you dont need to lie about our prophet saws
Take care