Which is nobler??Hinduism or Abrahamic Religion

[Abdullah Tahmeed]

A question asked by Hindu

Hindus have a concept that every religion leads to the path of Good(technically it is true, islam, christianity, hinduism, all are against lying, murder etc. etc.; some biblical verses or some parts maybe bad but overall all of the religions are against falsehood and crimes). And their karma system is totally based on good deeds and bad deeds, not based on believing the God.

Abrahamic religions have either believe in God or rot in hell forever concept. They have karma system but at the end of the day it is all believe the God.

Hindus have monism+pantheism based believe. Their concept is everything that exists is a part of super reality or a super soul called PARAMATMA. Even God is a part of this soul. The difference between God and Men is Men are not self realized. So basically, you can be in a higher stage of spirituality, as high as God. When you believe everything is part of same soul, you start believing in fraternity.

Abrahamic religions believe everything is a slave of God. So you lose your high spiritual position as in Hinduism. And every human is from same source as stated in quran but this fraternity is weaker than Hindu system as hindus believe everything is part of your soul(a bigger fraternity)

[submit]

Not sure if Hindu even regard Islam leading to good path..
 as they say Muslims worship God-Shiva.  Shiva is the God of War&Destruction. That's why Muslim love to destroy, this is what Hindu believe.

[Tahmeed]

Salam brothers,

Present Hinduism is nothing but nonsense. They say that all their gods are actually one, parts of that paramatma thing. But then why do they quarrel among themselves? Do you know that a myth says that Shiva chased some gods with a bow? If this kind of things happen, how is the world running so smoothly? Those Christians also say that there there three gods are actually one. But in different places we see that Jesus prays to God the Father. If they are truly one, why does he pray? And he also prays to take away the cup from him which means the Father and Jesus have independent minds! Read this;

"(Jesus is praying to the Father) And this is eternal life, that they may know You, THE ONLY TRUE GOD, and Jesus Christ whom you have sent."

Now Jesus was a Muslim.

And the Jews also love to call God their daddy and even calls themselves gods! (Psalm 82:6)

You want to find perfect monotheism? that's ISLAM.

And we don't worship some vulgar genital attached with a vagina. Is that something to worship?

Salam

Tahmeed

[Tarek Habbal]

Salam brother,

Is that even a question?

Are you comparing God's religion to a man made one?

Most of these man made religions are rooted in Jinn worship... In other words Satanism. Notice how most of their Gods in drawings are blue and standing on a checkered floor....

What is nobler? The worship of God, the Creator, the Originator, the One and Only, the Eternal, the Merciful... or the worship of the created?

Salam

[Abdullah Tahmeed]

Brother Tarek, the purpose of comparative religion is to compare different religions. And everyone calls their religion God's religion. But when you give dawah, you will have to talk from a neutral view.

However, the present hinduism is nonsense, but many educated ones have the pantheistic concept i mentioned above. Now if we  compare it with Islamic pure monotheism, how can we prove Monotheism to be better than their pantheism??

[Tarek Habbal]

True brother Abdallah, we have to be neutral while practicing Dawaa..

Talk to them about the Quran and the morals embedded in it.. the life of the Prophet (PBUH), the life and the rule of the first 4 Caliphs, as beacons of justice, honor and virtue,the Golden Age of Islam, when Muslims practiced real Islamic faith...

This should be enough proof of nobility

Salam

[Abdullah Tahmeed]

Hope this was so easy. Like i stated in my main post, in an apparent look Pantheism looks noble. We need to prove Islam wiser. when you look from islamic view: 
Talk to them about the Quran and the morals embedded in it.. the life of the Prophet (PBUH), the life and the rule of the first 4 Caliphs, as beacons of justice, honor and virtue,the Golden Age of Islam, when Muslims practiced real Islamic faith...

This is sufficient. But to others its not.

[Abu Abdullah]

[shabeer_hassan]

[Abdullah Tahmeed]

Brother Abu Abdullah,

Assalamu Alaikum, Well the thing you said is indeed true, but the thing is, the point you stated is a practical one. I have compared some beliefs of Abrahamic and some beliefs of Hindus which needs to be explained

[Abu Abdullah]

Assalamu alaikum brother tahmeed.
I have stated this example because unlike every other religion, islam is 100% practical. We implement and practise what we believe. But the other ones are not like this. That's why a practical exam is needed. Brother, beliefs cannot be compared or examined. We should also look for implementetions. Because, it is hard to make one believe something what one doesn't. But if the worldly implementetions are found useful it becomes easy for one to believe something.
And Allah knows best.