Answering Christianity Research Center

The problem isn't in the narrations themselves . They are in your own understanding .

First of all , apparently - no offense - you have no idea about the science of "Naskh" which is mentioned in Quran itself . A brief introduction is here :
http://www.eltwhed.com/vb/showthread.php?32190-%CD%E6%E1-%C7%E1%E4%C7%D3%CE-%E6%C7%E1%E3%E4%D3%E6%CE

Secondly , you deny that the prophet peace upon him was bewitched . And that is because of your misunderstanding and rashness really . You didn't mind the difference between bewitchment which harms one's health and what the disbelievers claimed that everything he said was of bewitchment . And how do you deny it while a prophet , Musa peace upon him , was bewitched AS THE NOBLE QURAN SAYS ?!
Taha 66 (He said, "Rather, you throw." And suddenly their ropes and staffs seemed to him from their magic that they were moving [like snakes].)
A prophet is a human and is not invincible to harm . However , the message itself is protected at any cost until it is delivered . That's why even when he was bewitched he never said anything wrong or incorrect about Allah and Islam .

So believe me , the main reason of this is what you call "emotional attacks" . Would it be so troublesome to look for an explanation to something you misunderstood ?

In Arabic , we call that a "lie with horns" .

1-  Do you believe that the Prophet got bewitched from a Jew who allegedly stole a piece of his hair?

Just a question : Why do you find it unrealistic while Quran says so about the prophet Musa peace upon him ?
Surah Taha sign 66 ((He said, "Rather, you throw." And suddenly their ropes and staffs seemed to him from their magic that they were moving [like snakes].))
There is no contradiction between this and "Isma" of the prophets as the narration of bewitchment doesn't say in anyway that the prophet peace upon him would tell wrong things about Allah . It doesn't matter what they would do , Allah will protect the message and the prophet will deliver it . This is a page about "Isma" , please read it :
http://articles.islamweb.net/media/index.php?page=article&lang=A&id=13441

2-  Do you believe that Aisha used to have her sister and/or cousin suckle adults to allow them to enter her house after the Prophet died?

Where is this one ? The one I know is a specific judgement for a specific companion and none else . This is the answer here :
http://www.almanhaj.com/vb/showthread.php?t=11650
http://fatwa.islamweb.net/fatwa/index.php?page=showfatwa&Option=FatwaId&Id=200111

3-  Do you believe that a she-monkey was stoned to death by a group of monkeys because the she-moneky committed adultery?

The narration isn't to the prophet peace upon him , neither is it to a companion , but rather to a follower "Tab'i" . That was his own opinion and it doesn't mean the narrator made a mistake .
http://www.elforkan.com/7ewar/showthread.php/1132-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B1%D8%AF-%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%89-%D8%B4%D8%A8%D9%87%D8%A9-%D8%AD%D8%AF%D9%8A%D8%AB-%D8%B1%D8%AC%D9%85-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%B1%D8%AF%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B2%D8%A7%D9%86%D9%8A%D8%A9
Not to mention that it is indeed possible . A little look at a documentary about monkeys should help :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CPznMbNcfO8
Even monkeys don't approve of betrayal of spouse .

4-  Do you believe Imam Bukhari memorized 600,000 Hadiths?  If so, how was that verified according to you?

If a narration is mentioned with multiple different chains , each chain is considered one Hadith . Not to mention that among them there are weak and fabricated ones which he didn't mention in his Sahih but rather in "The weak chain" (Assilsila Adda'iifa) .
http://www.eltwhed.com/vb/showthread.php?11542-%DF%CA%C8-%C7%E1%D6%C7%E1-%DF%ED%DD-%C7%D3%CA%D8%C7%DA-%C7%E1%C8%CE%C7%D1%ED-%ED%D8%C7%E1%DA-600-%C3%E1%DD-%D1%E6%C7%ED%C9-!!!

5-  Do you believe Imam Ahmed memorized 1,000,000 Hadiths?  If so, how was that verified according to you?

http://islamqa.info/ar/171298
The same as the above . But seriously , if the reason you refuse this is because you don't see it makes sense or it isn't possible , I also won't believe these people reported to speak a wide variety of languages !
http://sciencefocus.com/qa/what-record-most-languages-spoken-one-person
Notice that one of them was tested on TV .

6-  Do you believe the dajjal (anti-Christ) is currently chained in an Island somewhere in lala land?  The Sahih volumes report on Muslims who actually saw him.  I even saw a Youtube video in the past suggesting that it might've been England.

England or not , that's a personal opinion which might be true or not . And I say "So what of it ?" . And before you just decide that something is wrong and talk about it in such a manner - lala land ?! - why not ask or see for yourself if you misunderstood something ? Again , what of it ? Do you find it impossible to believe ? And on what bases do you think that ? Allah can do anything ? He keeps this man alive until he's released as a "Fitnah" to test people and see the real believers . Do you say Allah can't do that ? Or maybe you say we would have already found him ? Seriously ? You don't believe it because you can't find him with those so called satellites ? Here's a gift my friend : Discovery of a cave with over 51 thousand square meters in China . It even has its own climate .
http://www.eltwhed.com/vb/showthread.php?54716-%C7%DF%CA%D4%C7%DD-%DF%E5%DD-%E3%D3%C7%CD%CA%E5-51000%E32&highlight=%C7%DF%CA%D4%C7%DD+%DF%E5%DD

7-  Do you believe Prophet Moses punched the Angel of Death in the eye when he came to take his soul, because Moses' life has expired?  Allah Almighty supposedly extended Moses' life because of this punch.  Yet, this CLASHES WITH THE HOLY QURAN about none can advance nor reduce their appointed time!  Everyone is scheduled to die at their due time.

http://fatwa.islamweb.net/fatwa/index.php?page=showfatwa&Option=FatwaId&Id=78366
http://www.eltwhed.com/vb/showthread.php?21184-%C7%E1%D1%CF-%DA%E1%EC-%E3%E4-%C3%E4%DF%D1-%DD%DE%C3-%DA%ED%E4-%E3%E1%DF-%C7%E1%E3%E6%CA
http://www.ahlalhdeeth.com/vb/showthread.php?t=178585
When we see something seemingly contradicting Quran we look into it . If it's unauthorized then it's immediately discarded . If it is , we could be misunderstanding it and in this case we look at a proper explanation to it .

Furthermore, we never see the so-called "Mawdu (injected, fabricated)" hadiths ever burnt or removed permanently.  They still remain in all of the hadiths collections.  They still endure.  Why?  Isn't it because you're giving nothing but opinionated nonsense that not everyone of your "scholars" agrees with you on?  So at the end of the day, you guys are playing nothing but games of opinions on the expense of Islam.

1-  If the hadith is a lie, then why not remove it??

2-  If the hadith is a doubt, why not remove it??

3-  Did not Allah Almighty forbid us to live on conjectures, in the Holy Quran?

Are you serious ?! You want to change what someone wrote ?! Some scientists used to believe matter is formed of sand , water , fire , and wind . We still see what they wrote and it isn't removed . We are not to change what someone has written . Scholars declare weak as weak , fabricated as fabricated , but none of them would say "Remove it" because that would be dishonesty .

I don't know how you talk about emotional attacks while you call whatever you don't agree with as rubbish and nonsense .

Don't be my Dictionary, I know the difference I Would have written that in a rush.

A nice way to not answer how you put words in my mouth .

Lolz You Psychopath?? Have you even read that??? if you are putting that as reference then You yourself is against you, there was nothing to prove your point.

And now it's a psychopath ? Anyway , here they are again in English if you can't understand Arabic :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_ibn_Ya%27qub_al-Kulayni
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muhammad_Baqir_Majlisi
And note that it says they are scholars of Shiism . Case closed . So you should be lashing at them for giving a negative view of shia not me .

Who Do you think You are?? Am I on your GUN point So lie or DEny?? YOU're brain Washed Bro... I Wallahi Not scared of any human beings But ALLah the Almighty..  I would never lie or deny anything which is true about us, but if its false no matter how hard You try I will DENy and DENYY.

I'm beginning to think that you either don't understand plain English or you don't understand basic logic . When I give you evidence of something , either you say that what they do is not of your Shiism and that they are wrong , or admit it . You apparently do neither . Do I have to make it simple again ? Fine . You must either answer my point and show me if I'm wrong about it , deem yourself innocent of them the same way we all deem ourselves innocent of violence against the innocent - Yeah , a lot of "innocent mentioning , whatever - , or admit that it's true . So what will you do ?

Let's Face it how many WEbpages You want me to show you that says MUslim are Terrorist Just because of you People American People Burn QUran, just because of you People Israelis made a crap film of Our Prophet Muhammad (SAW).

You can take this statement and throw it in the nearest trash dumb . Jews and Christians hate us ever since the beginning of Islam . Wither 0.04 of Muslims act violently or not isn't going to change how they look at us . They are used to lie in all different ways to divert people from truth . Put a face if you want , I don't care . And after hearing this part of your rant , WHAT DOES THAT HAVE TO DO WITH ANYTHING ?!

THE irani People were the first who yell against the people who made that film against our prophet.. where were SAUDI arabia that time WHo do you think you are to JUDGE me and MY PEOPLE???

I don't care in the slightest about Iran , Saudia Arabia , or any other forsaken country which makes the so called "nationality" more important than brotherhood in Islam . Trying to make an emotional attack through "You're from Saudia Arabia so you suck , I'm Iranian so I rule" is pathetic .

I clearly say that all Pages he put there are in Arabic, and the majority of SHIA people understand PERSIAN or FARSI in my Country where SHIA mostly live if I'm not wrong which doesnt matter though... People like You Allow SUICIDE Bombing, CAlling Kaffir other people, Putting allegations on others, try to demolish people where Human beings lives have no value for you. where as OUR prophet (pbuh) brought the message of peace and harmony.

Again , take this statement and throw it in the nearest trash dumb along with the rest of your rant . Claiming we allow suicide is a low shot showing your true value . And when someone has NOTHING at all except emotional attacks , you know he's got NOTHING .
Arabic or not , what's the point ? You used a translation of Quran so does that make it fake ?

Written in ARABIC, revealed in ARABIC, Distributed in ARABIC and read ARABIC people....  OMG!!!! and you call them references?? I ask you how many SHIA people you met and asked them??

Arabic or not means nothing ! So what ? You're telling me all Shia are Persian ? If you say so then you're absolutely out of your mind . Wither those books were written in Persian or Arabic doesn't matter . If Persian , the pages I brought are translations . No meaning in your "Arabic sucks" nonsense .

And after all this heap of trash you think we'll be cool if you call me "Brother" ?! Keep in mind that this thread started fine as a conversation but you're the one who bloody acted like a retarded moron who understands NOTHING of what I say ! YOU'RE the one who started calling me psychotic and brain washed because you're simply afraid to respond with a meaningful argument ! YOU'RE the one who put words in my mouth and ranted like a 5 years old ! So deal with the consequences of your bloody actions , go learn logic and a bit of English , and shut up and spare us the headache !!

hey Brother let me tell you ALL shia do follow the five pillars of Islam, and Many other things don't bring that again and again. I told you we do follow so accept it and don't say sunni agrees on pillars I surely know All shia do.

You know , we have an old saying "If you have sand on your head , feel it" . It means that if it doesn't address you , don't talk about it . You follow the pillars ? Good . Then you're not one of those I'm addressing .

are You OK? putting all in ARABIC? let me tell the majority of Shia are in Iran. and they don't write arabic and so.

You told me you can understand a bit . And I told you I'm not good with references in English .

I couldn't understand what was written in all those references but let me clear they all are modified books if there is any thing wrong. as you have asked me, I told you they are false Shai don't do that.

Refusing all those books is meaningless through saying "They must be modified" . I took them straight from Shia websites and they are in PDF . That means they are pictures of the real life books . Those are written scholars of Shiism . If you have a problem with anyone , you should have it with them and deem them wrong instead of yelling at me .

many of the allegation you asked I already denied that they all are false. So don't bring that again and again. I'm not scared of any1 so I never lie (Allhamdullillah) to you that we don't do that and these. IF we shia DO anything and U ask about it, I surely will tell about it as I know I'm not wrong as far I'm Following Quran and Sunnah. So If I'm denying the allegation DON't PASS it AGAIN PLEASE.

Again , if you have sand on your head , touch it .

WHO said companions are apostates?? I told you that they only criticize UMAR (RA) and Aisha but they never say apostate to any one.

And who do they think themselves to criticize people whom Allah promised paradise ?! You were just saying I don't have the right to criticize people ! But when it comes to the companions it's OK ?! Or am I missing something here ? Once more , touch the sand .

So in the end , it proves that there are people and scholars among Shia who do accuse the companions of blasphemy , view Ali may Allah be pleased of him as a God , and worship the dead . If you're mad at someone , be mad at them .

I also know that there are a group of Sunni who says suicide Bombing "IN ANY CASE" are allowed.

They hold no evidence to their claim the same way those shia don't . That's why we bring forth proof . Anyway , check the other thread .

Secondly, I shattered in Piece when u said that "I'm not sure about the differences between shia" and in the last line u have posted something like "They claim Ali may Allah be pleased of him is a god and has created everything , others say that Jibreel peace upon him - innocent he is from what they say - didn't do his duty and delivered the message to prophet Muhammad peace upon him instead of Ali". I ask you If u say that u r not sure about the difference Why u have posted something which is totally wrong about the Shia People. WE HAVE NEVER CONSIDERED ALI (pbuh) A god!!!!!!!

I mentioned the ones I know and hear speaking in this exact way . If you're not of then then it isn't directed at you . That is why I always say "The type of shia I know" because I won't judge the ones I don't .
And let me ask you here : What is the difference you have that you call yourself shia ? From a number of narrations to the prophet peace upon him we find out that the group following his true teachings is called "Ahl Assuna wa Al-Jama'a" meaning the ones who follow his sunna and remain by his group . So what's the difference ?

Why you people criticize Shia People with something which is thoroughly wrong. WALLahi, my Heart Breaks into Parts Wallahi I won't forgive anyone who criticize Shia People, Wallahi I seek justice from Almighty Allah for those Muslims who are not aware of what Other People are spreading against Shia.

Ali , I can easily give you links to sites and videos of some of those who do what we're saying they do . I didn't just claim so out of nothing or just because I heard it from someone . I saw and heard with my own two ears .

Brother who told you that Shia People are accusing the companions of "kufr".
Allhamdulliah We do respect the 4 companions of Prophet Muhammad (SAW) (pbuh)

It isn't just the for successors but the whole nation of the companions . Anyway , if you do , then you're not one of those I mentioned .

Though, without any doubt we Love Hazara Ali (RA) the most. This is Our love for him and I pretty sure unconditional love is not "kfr" in Islam.

Although there are narrations saying that the best of the companions was Abu Bakr may Allah be pleased of him , that's something for another time , but yes , favoring Ali may Allah be pleased of him isn't "Kufr" .

and what is this worship of dead??? where have u read allllllllllll theseeeeeeeee!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! every Shia recites "Surat Al-'Ikhlāş" thousand times a day I'm pretty sure you understand the meaning of "Surat Al-'Ikhlāş" how can U say Shia worship dead etc whilst every single child, young, men, women, old recites "Surat Al-'Ikhlāş". I have thousands of words to say and ask but first ALL I want the References of what you have posted here about Shia people.

Can you read Arabic ? Because I'm not so good with finding references in English . This is a video of some forbidden acts in decorating graves
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R0qbkESwlR4
That isn't itself worship of the dead , but still :
http://www.dd-sunnah.net/forum/showthread.php?t=149078
You may want to zoom out with CTRL and (-) because the font is a little big .

Are you kidding me ? A society which doesn't leave any sort of sexual activities without committing them dares talk about incest ? And saying that one's cousin is "like" his sister doesn't make her his sister neither does adopting a person - which is forbidden in Islam by the way - make him your son . And although I asked someone some time ago about marrying a cousin and I was told there is nothing forbidding it , I'll wait and see the narration saying so .