Peace
I found many hadiths that state that non muslims be expelled from Arabia.
http://sunnah.com/search/expel-arabian-peninsula
However, history has shown us that non Muslims were still living their, The prophet didn't expel them and neither did Abu Bakr, Umar expelled the jews of Khaybar after they attacked Abdullah ibn Umaar and broke his arm, and he expelled them from hijaz, and he allowed them to visit hijaz for a 3 day visit. The christians of najran were expelled only after they broke a treaty.
These are found in history books and hadith.
isn't this a contradiction.
As'salamu Alaikum dear brother,
I am not sure where is the contradiction that you're talking about. The order of the Prophet, peace be upon him, was to expel all NON-MUSLIMS (no exceptions) from the Holy Lands. Apparently, the order took sometime to be fully executed. It's not like the Prophet can say to something "Be" and then it becomes.
I don't see a contradiction. The problem that some narrations have, is that they have too lengthy narration chain, as just about every single one you gave had. Obviously, some of these are either out of historical context, or out of context, or were isolated situation. The Grand Order was to expel all non-Muslims out of the Holy Lands. That we all agree upon. The problem that you're raising is that some Jews and non-Muslims remained until Umar became a Caliph.
Well as you know, the Muslims had to deal with many many battles after the liberation of Mecca. Wars with pagans and apostates (the army of the hypocrites), as you know, took place. They wanted to destroy Islam and miserably failed. Not only Islam prevailed and crushed all of them and converted all of Arabia to Islam, but Islam further conquored Persia and much Rome's lands.
So it would make sense that some of the rotten Zionists remained in Arabia only because the Muslims just simply didn't have the chance nor the time to reach them. But after the pagans and apostates (the army of the hypocrites and fake "Muslims") got crushed, then the time was suitable to clear our lands from all Zionist filth. This is similar to the rotten idol-worshiping shias and their zionist imams in our lands today. It'll take time to get rid of them. But the Grand Goal is to remove all of them, insha'Allah.
Like the apostates, pagans and zionists 1,400 years ago, we also today don't need these zionist Islam-corruptors in our Holy Lands. Insha'Allah, the corrupt royal family will be thrown out of our Holy Lands along with them, as well. We must clean our Holy Lands from those rubbish as well.
The Arab Spring was born and the people errupted against the dictators. After the fall of Iraq, so many armed militias were formed throughout the Middle East. Praised be Allah Almighty, the Arabs have risen against their governments, and they will NOT stop. The Arab world now is FILLED with well-armed militias. And it will only grow and get better, insha'Allah. These guys are now even building their own weapons. Regardless of how long their victory will take, but it'll happen, insha'Allah, and REAL ISLAM will be restored, insha'Allah.
The shias' fatal mistake was that they clashed with the Arab Spring. Alhamdulillah that they did. The overwhelming majority of the Muslims world-wide were ignorants of zionist shiism. And the Shias are finding out the hard way that they're on their way to extermination like rodents from one's home. So both the shias and our dictators and their filthy royal families will be exterminated like rodents from our home, insha'Allah (if Allah Almighty is Willing). It will take time, but it'll happen for sure, insha'Allah.
Rest assured that the
Middle East WILL NEVER EVER be the same again. Those
"Iron Fists" that were ruling us got chopped off! Thanks to George W. Bush and his Crusader Holy War on Saddam Hussein. Allah Almighty with His Divine Will and Wisdom Chose that clown and his neo-con zionist slaves to do it. With close to 2 trillion US dollars, Bush was able to do it. And now the Middle East is all armed militias, and they are rapidly growing. But the difference between them and the militias that are in Latin America and Africa is that ISLAM KEEPS THEM EITHICAL AND MORAL & REAL SOLDIERS OF ALLAH ALMIGHTY, while the others that I mentioend turn to
drug cartels and gangs and thugs who terrorize their own people with rapes and murders by the wholesale.
Look at Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt, Libya. Complete chaos. And by the way,
Bangladesh and Pakistan are boiling right now. Insha'Allah that part of the Muslim world will errupt soon, and the Muslims will clear their lands from the filthy and corrupt dictators and their royal families that are robbing their lands. Believe me, the Muslim world is changing, and is changing for the better, insha'Allah.
I hope this helps, insha'Allah.
Take care,
Osama Abdallah
