Show Posts
46
GENERAL TOPICS | BOARD ANNOUNCEMENTS / Need refutation please
« on: January 23, 2017, 11:33:39 AM »
Surah 2:275 - Zaid text - Allathiina yaakuluunar-ribaa laa yaquumuun - "those that devour usury will not stand"
Mas'ud text - Allathiina yaakuluunar-ribaa laa yaquumuun yawmal qiyaamati - "those that devour usury will not stand IN THE RESURRECTION DAY."
Surah 5:89 (listed as 5:91 by Gilchrist) - Zaid text - Fasiyaamu thalaathati ayyaamin - "fast for three days"
Mas'ud text - Fasiyaamu thalaathati ayyaamin mutataabi'aatin - "fast for three SUCCESSIVE days"
Surah 6:153 - Zaid text - Wa anna haathaa siraatii - "Verily this is my path"
Mas'ud text - Wa haathaa siraatu rabbakum - "This is the path OF YOUR LORD"
Incidentally, the text of Ubayy ibn Ka'b also has this reading, except that the word rabbakum is replaced with rabbika.
Surah 33:6 - Zaid text - Wa azwaajuhuu ummahaatuhuu - "and his wives are their mothers"
Mas'ud text - Wa azwaajuhuu ummahaatuhuu wa huwa abuu laahum - "and his wives are their mothers AND HE IS THEIR FATHER."
The Ibn Ka'b text has these same words, but reverses the statements about Mohammed's wives being mothers and he being a father to the Muslim community, placing the statement about Mohammed first.
Yet, they are not. Samuel Green, in his work, The Different Arabic Versions of the Qur'an60, makes a note of many of the differences in reading between these two particular transmissions, some of which I will give below. Please note, the difference in ayat references are due to the difference in the numbering systems between the two Qur'ans, but they refer to the words in question from the same passages:
Surah 3:133 (Hafs) - wasaari'uu
Surah 3:133 (Warsh) - saari‘uu
Surah 2:140 (Hafs) - taquluna
Surah 2:139 (Warsh) - yaquluna
Surah 3:81 (Hafs) - ataytukum
Surah 3:80 (Warsh) - ataynakum
Surah 2:259 (Hafs) - nunshizuhaa
Surah 2:258 (Warsh) - nunshiruhaa
Surah 2:10 (Hafs) - yakdhibuuna
Surah 2:9 (Warsh) - yukadhdhibuuna
Surah 2:184 (Hafs) - ta'aamu miskiinin
Surah 2:183 (Warsh) - ta'aami masakiina
Mas'ud text - Allathiina yaakuluunar-ribaa laa yaquumuun yawmal qiyaamati - "those that devour usury will not stand IN THE RESURRECTION DAY."
Surah 5:89 (listed as 5:91 by Gilchrist) - Zaid text - Fasiyaamu thalaathati ayyaamin - "fast for three days"
Mas'ud text - Fasiyaamu thalaathati ayyaamin mutataabi'aatin - "fast for three SUCCESSIVE days"
Surah 6:153 - Zaid text - Wa anna haathaa siraatii - "Verily this is my path"
Mas'ud text - Wa haathaa siraatu rabbakum - "This is the path OF YOUR LORD"
Incidentally, the text of Ubayy ibn Ka'b also has this reading, except that the word rabbakum is replaced with rabbika.
Surah 33:6 - Zaid text - Wa azwaajuhuu ummahaatuhuu - "and his wives are their mothers"
Mas'ud text - Wa azwaajuhuu ummahaatuhuu wa huwa abuu laahum - "and his wives are their mothers AND HE IS THEIR FATHER."
The Ibn Ka'b text has these same words, but reverses the statements about Mohammed's wives being mothers and he being a father to the Muslim community, placing the statement about Mohammed first.
Yet, they are not. Samuel Green, in his work, The Different Arabic Versions of the Qur'an60, makes a note of many of the differences in reading between these two particular transmissions, some of which I will give below. Please note, the difference in ayat references are due to the difference in the numbering systems between the two Qur'ans, but they refer to the words in question from the same passages:
Surah 3:133 (Hafs) - wasaari'uu
Surah 3:133 (Warsh) - saari‘uu
Surah 2:140 (Hafs) - taquluna
Surah 2:139 (Warsh) - yaquluna
Surah 3:81 (Hafs) - ataytukum
Surah 3:80 (Warsh) - ataynakum
Surah 2:259 (Hafs) - nunshizuhaa
Surah 2:258 (Warsh) - nunshiruhaa
Surah 2:10 (Hafs) - yakdhibuuna
Surah 2:9 (Warsh) - yukadhdhibuuna
Surah 2:184 (Hafs) - ta'aamu miskiinin
Surah 2:183 (Warsh) - ta'aami masakiina
