CAPTIVES OF BANU AL MUSTALIQ: RAPED OR RELEASED

[Affan Khan]

[Affan Khan]

WATCH OUT BROTHER AND SISTERS CRITICS WILL SURELY QUOTE FROM
AL WAQIDI VOL 1 PAGE 413  WHERE IT DOES SAYS THAT ABU SAID AL KHUDRI(RA) PERFORMED AZL AND TOOK THE SLAVE GIRL TO SELL HER
WHICH IS AGAIN NOT SUPPORTED BY ANY EVIDENCE OF BEING SAHIH OR EVEN DAIF


EVEN AFTER THE CONTEXT EXPLAINED PEOPLE MAY FIND THE PHRASES IN THE CONTEXT OF  THIS HADITH SUCH AS
"WE DESIRED THE WOMEN" "WE LOVED TO DO COITUS INTERRUPTUS"
WHICH LEADS TO THE DISINTEGRATION OF SAHABA'S PICTURE IN OUR MINDS POSING THEM AS ANY OTHER HUMAN BEINGS MAKING US SAD AND UNCOMFORT BUT AS I SAID
MOST OF THE LAWS SPECIALLY IDDAH LAW WAS NOT REVEALED TO PROPHET SO IT WAS QUITE NATURAL FOR THEM TO WANT IN THAT WAY
BUT THE GENEROSITY AND HUMANNESS OF SAHABA CAN BE EASILY WITNESSED IN THE HADITH FOLLOWED WERE THEY RELEASED ALL CAPTIVES.
THEY WERE NOT RAPISTS NEITHER SEX HUNGRY
WELL I ACTUALLY DON'T KNOW HOW MANY FAMILIES WERE MADE CAPTIVES
INDEED ALLAH KNOWS BEST!!!

[Affan Khan]

Aslaam walaikum please can some one make this as an article on answering christianity .Com

[submit]

Under Jewish law, a Rabbi will say a soldier can rape a girl  to relinquish his sexual desire during war one time only. As this is permitted by Yhwh in their books.

But in the story shared by Brother Affan, we saw that no sexual act happened during war.

Sex during war time is rape.
Sex with captive after war ended with conditions to be met is not rape.

[Affan Khan]

Please brothers make this as an article and tell the reality to as much as people as possible.
Because I gave this explanation in the comments box of youtube.
So a muslim brother said that he was just about to leave Islam

[Affan Khan]

REASONS I COMPARED THIS SCENERIO WITH MUTAH MARRIAGE
1)THIS WAS JUST A HIGHLY EXCEPTIONAL CASE NO OTHER HADITH EVEN TALKS SELLING OF SLAVE WOMEN THAT TOO AFTER HAVING SEX WITH THEM
2)ISLAM ALLOWS SEX WITH SLAVE GIRL BUT DOSEN'T ALLOWS "USING" THE SLAVE GIRL FOR PHYSICAL PELEASURE.
THIS EXCEPTIONAL CASE RATHER SEEMS CONTRADICTORY THATS WHY I COMPARED WITH MUTAH MARRIAGE.
3) http://www.letmeturnthetables.com/2012/09/no-rape-slave-women-islam.html
WILL CLARIFY THE DOUBTS
4)(24:32) Marry those of you that are single, (whether men or women),50 and those of your male and female slaves that are righteous.51,52 If they are poor, Allah will enrich them out of His Bounty.53 Allah is Immensely Resourceful, All-Knowing.
?
(24:33) Let those who cannot afford to marry keep themselves chaste until Allah enriches them out of His Bounty.54 And write out a deed of manumission for such of your slaves that desire their freedom55 in lieu of payment56 - if you see any good in them57 - and give them out of the wealth that Allah has given you.58 And do not compel your slave-girls to prostitution for the sake of the benefits of worldly life the while they desire to remain chaste.59 And if anyone compels them to prostitution, Allah will be Most Pardoning, Much Merciful (to them) after their subjection to such compulsion.
HERE ALLAH MADE THE DOORS OF FREEDOM OPEN FOR ALL SLAVES AND SLVE GIRLS THAT THEY CAN BE MARRIED AMONG THEMSELVES AND AND WORK THEIR WAY TO ATTAIN FREEDOM.
5)ONE OF THE MOST IMP POINT THAT IDDAH LAW IS HIGHLY SIGNIFICANT IN THIS RESPECT AS IT WILL AUTOMATICALLY AVOID THESE SITUATIONS
6)MUTAH MARRIAGE WAS PROHIBITED BECAUSE IT IS CONSIDERED AS A FORM OF ADULTERY
SIMILARLY USING SLAVE WOMEN ON TEMPORARY BASIS WOULD AGAIN BE AUTOMATICALLY PROHIBITED AND AFTER REVEALATION OF ABOVE QURANIC AYAHS IT IS QUITE CLEAR THAT ISLAM PROHIBITS PROSTITUTING AND USING THE SLAVE WOMEN OF PHYSICAL PLEASURE AND WORDLY GAINS.
if a miltary commander permitted his soldiers to temporarily use the female captives as objects of sexual desire and distributed them among the soldiers for that purpose, such an act would be considered unlawful by Islamic Law. Such an act is not essentially different from fornication or adultery. For details see book Tafhimat, vol. 2, pp. 366-84, and Rasai'il wa Masa'il, 6th edition, Lahore, 1976, vol. 3, pp. 102-4.
7)
INDEED ALLAH KNOWS BEST!!!