The fabricated hadith, which contains a great trap, says the following:
The Messenger of Allah (saw) said: "If you had not committed any sin, Allah would have destroyed you and created in your place those who would have committed sin (but whom He would have forgiven because of their repentance)." Muslim, Tawbah, 9, (2748); Tirmidhi, Da'awat 105, (3533)
So according to this rumor/rumor, if a society never sins, it will be destroyed. But of course this lie was invented to mislead people and lead them to sin.
The truth, of course, is the opposite. Our Lord does not destroy a society if it never sins, but on the contrary, He destroys it if it sins, and He informs us of this in the Qur'an:
Surah Yunus Surah 13 By Allah, We destroyed the generations before you because they committed wrongdoing and did not believe when their messengers brought them clear proofs. This is how We punish the sinful people.
Surat al-Isra: 17 And how many generations We destroyed after Noah, and your Lord is sufficient as a Reckoner and Seer of the sins of His servants.
Surah Araf
4 How many a land and civilization did We bring down. And Our torment came upon them at night or at midday when they were asleep.
5 And when Our punishment came upon them, what they did was nothing but raise this cry: We were indeed wrongdoers.
Surah Al-An'am 6 Have they not seen how many a land and civilization We destroyed before them? And We gave to those lands what We did not give you in the earth, and We sent down upon them the blessings of the sky in abundance, and We made the rivers flow beneath them. Then We destroyed them for their own sins and raised up another generation after them.
Moreover, our Lord does not destroy societies that compete in goodness and stay away from sin and forbidden behavior, but rather blesses them in this world and offers them a beautiful paradise-like life:
Hud 117: Your Lord will not destroy cities as long as their inhabitants behave righteously.
Anfal 53. This is so. For Allah does not change the blessing He bestows on a people unless they change what is in them as individuals/what pertains to them as individuals. And Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing
Surah Jinn
16. And if they had walked in the way, We would have watered them with abundant water,
17. That We may test them in it. And whoever turns away from the remembrance of his Lord (the Qur'an), his Lord will cause him to enter into a torment of increasing torment.
Araf 96 Had the inhabitants of those civilizations believed and protected themselves, We would certainly have showered on them blessings from heaven and earth. But they denied, so We seized them with what they had earned.
As we can see, the hadith doctrine seeks to make the philosophical basis of the Qur'an (Islam) the their wanting philosophical basis by trying to make people adopt the opposite of the Qur'anic teaching (Islam). So who was it that wanted to make sin look innocent to people and used the mask of religion for this purpose?
Surah Araf Surah 11 And certainly We created you, then We fashioned you, then We said to the angels: "Prostrate yourselves to Adam," and they did so. But Iblis did not, he was not of those who prostrate.
Surah A'raf: 16 He said: "I swear by your misleading me that I will be set upon your straight path to lead them astray."
Surat al-Fatir 5 O people, the promise of Allah is true! So let not the life of this world deceive you! And let not that great deceiver, that proud one, deceive you with Allah.
As stated in the verses, this jinn (Iblis) tries to lead people to sin with various lies.
Surah Araf
9. "O Adam! You and your wife dwell in Paradise, and eat from wherever you like, but do not come near that tree. Otherwise both of you will be among the wrongdoers."
20. Then Satan tempted them both to reveal to them their ugly parts which were hidden from them. He said: "Your Lord has kept you away from that tree so that you may not become two angels or join the immortals."
Satan has been trying to play the same game throughout history, ever since the first human being. If he directly calls people to evil, many people might run away from him, but he captures them with many tricks, masks and by cooking their minds step by step. Pay close attention to this trap. It is set on the right path and aims to lead people to misery in this world and the Hereafter...
And the main doctrine that this genie has been using throughout history to slip people's feet has been Spiritualism/Paganism.
I am giving our video on the subject again:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EXA38GeVM6k Since the Spiritualist doctrine aims to send people to hell, one of the ways it does this is by trying to make sin seem innocent, even necessary. By making people embrace the beliefs of progress and absolute duality, it has the subtlety to present evil and suffering as if they were necessary to attain salvation. To this end, they have even tried to degenerate religion by altering old books like the Bible, which was not protected.
But the Qur'an was under the protection of Allah and therefore could not be touched by humans and jinns, and so they attempted to impose the superstition that the Qur'an was inadequate on the society, and to make hadiths, sectarian and Sufi teachings (and therefore spiritism) part of the religion.
In fact, as our Lord said, the only religious source left to us and protected was our holy book, and we should only cling to it in the field of religion:
Surah Al-Jaziya 6 These are the signs of Allah, which We recite to you in truth. And yet, after Allah and His verses, which hadith/saying do they believe in?
We have left nothing lacking in the Book.
Surah 6-Anam 38
The only source on earth that is protected from spiritism/paganism is the Qur'an, and it is by turning to it that we can learn the religion of Allah and arrive at the correct philosophy of life/testing.
The famous hadith/ narration that is the subject of this article, on the other hand, not only perpetrates the corruption of making the world a place of progress and not a place of testing, but also tries to create the impression that Allah wants His servants to make mistakes and get into trouble.
The interesting thing is that this hadith has become so accepted that many people even take it as a verse...
Let us repeat: Our Lord is not destroying societies that do not sin, but destroying sinful and evil societies and replacing them with good and good people. And He starts rewarding those individuals and communities who stay away from sin even in this world:
Surah Al-Anfal
51. "This is because of what your hands have sent before you. Allah is never unjust to the servants."
52. Just as was the case with the house of Pharaoh and those before them. They denied the signs of Allah and Allah seized them for their sins. Allah is the Mighty, the All-powerful, and He is the Most severe in punishment.
53. This is so. For Allah does not change the favor He bestows on a people unless they change what is in them as individuals. And Allah is All-Hearing, All-Knowing
Surah Muhammad: 38 So you are the people who are called to spend in the way of Allah. But some of you are stingy. But he who is stingy is stingy to his own detriment. Allah is the Glorified; it is you who are poor. If you turn away, Allah will bring in your place another people. And they will not be like you.
And our Lord says that He will throw the societies He has destroyed and will destroy into Hell in the Hereafter. From this we can easily realize that Allah will not destroy a society that does not sin in this world. Because it is known that the good ones, those who follow the verses, will go to paradise...
Think about it, even a single sin can sometimes lead to a chain of other sins and troubles. As with most wrongdoing, the least should be avoided as much as possible.
Surah Al-Ma'idah 90 O you who believe! Drugs/wine, gambling, stones set up to be worshipped, and fortune-telling arrows are filth from Satan; avoid them so that you may be saved.
Furthermore, the Spiritualist doctrine does another "gimmick" in that it tries to portray not sinning at all as "godliness", suggesting that those who abstain from sin completely are excessive. However, people in heaven, for example, do not sin at all and this has nothing to do with deification (nor does being immortal in the afterlife...):
Surah Al-Vaqiah 25. They will not hear therein any idle talk, nor anything to tempt them to sin.
If a person or group of people were never going to sin, Allah would know this even before He created them, so it is conceivable (if we are doing mental gymnastics) that He would have created them directly in Paradise. That is, they would never experience the troubles of this world. But even in that case, it would not be a question of creating them on earth (in the universe) and then destroying them. They would have already started their life in paradise directly...
***
Our Lord commands us to stay away from sin, while Iblis, the enemy of mankind, calls us to sin.
While Allah tells Adam and his wife to "stay away from that tree", Iblis directs them to the haram with the lie "come closer to the tree, it will make you grow". In the same way, the hadith I gave at the beginning of this article tries to glorify and even glamorize sin. It contains the same trap...
This incident alone illustrates very effectively why people should stay away from rumors and narrations called hadith. Unfortunately, people are being skillfully indoctrinated with a philosophy that is the exact opposite of Islamic teaching... The situation is similar with the unprotected Bible and other older books, which are now also non-religious.
The Qur'an, on the other hand, as the only protected book, presents the true Islam and enlightens us, and humanity should accept the Qur'an as the only religious guide, i.e. His words, without associating any other book or source, as commanded by Almighty Allah...
(My Turkish article translated with machine)
http://emre1974tr.blogspot.com/2011/12/meshur-uydurma-hadisteki-yonlendirmeye.htmlPeace
